I’ve noticed something: when it comes to money, people tend to be loosey-goosey during the good times—taking shark-sized bites out of their monthly cash flow by increasing their debt load—and then try to unload everything they possibly can to stay afloat during the bad times. It’s one extreme to the other:

Good times = lease a new car, renovate a room, buy shiny new appliances, charge up the credit cards because we will be able to pay them off with our future income, daily lattes, etc.

Bad times = no lattes, cancel magazine subscriptions, cancel cable, sell the timeshare we never should have bought, unplug electronics when not in use, etc.

This post may contain affiliate links - it's how we keep the lights on around here. Here's our policy.

Whatever Happened to Moderation?

We’ve seen this play out recently with the Recession. Prior to the fall of 2008, the national personal savings rate (PSR: personal savings as a percentage of disposable personal income) was just around 0.7%. By the end of October 2008 when there were markets crashing, an uptick in foreclosures, general collapse of the housing market, tightening of credit lending and everyone was talking about the shark-infested waters ahead, the PSR climbed to 2.4%. That may not sound like much, but since the mid-1970s the rate has been cascading down, down, down, and down some more. In fact a higher PSR was sustained throughout the entire Recession than in the period leading up to it. This means that while people were in a better position financially, they chose to spend their resources instead of stock them away. They were part-time lovers of frugality.

Frugality is No Longer “the New Black”

Who wouldn’t tighten up their belts, pay down existing debts, and stash money away in savings with such a bleak economy? Yet, here we are just five years later and frugality is wearing off. It’s no longer “the new black”. Today the PSR seems to be floundering again. It is currently 4.4%, which is much better than the pre-recession 0.7%. However, if you look at the chart, it has plateaued. People have begun to flock back to their pre-recession, loosey-goosey ways. Credit card debt is increasing, auto loans are increasing, and student loans are increasing.


But what about maintaining frugality in the good times? You see, tightening your finances and being frugal will certainly allow you to survive bad financial times. But if you only use frugality during the bad times, you will fail to reap its full benefits. When you practice frugality just to survive, you don’t get the chance to stockpile. During the good times is when you can sock away money into your savings from living a simpler life, and when you can fill your cupboards until they are overflowing. And how do you save up for an emergency fund, the great neutralizer during the bad times? By practicing frugality when times are good.

You really reap the benefits of frugality when you use it during the good times, not just when you are sweating financial bullets. Click to TWEET ME

It’s important for us to remember that the cost of what we are buying during the good times is not just what we spend on that particular day. The real cost will be felt more in the times when we are in need. Don’t be a part-time lover of frugality. Be a full-time lover, and reap the full-time benefits.

10 replies
  1. Bryce @ Save and Conquer
    Bryce @ Save and Conquer says:

    I agree. People need to remember that living below your means is something that should be followed all the time. The good news is that the US personal savings rate in July was 4.4%. This is below the average since 1959 of 6.9%, but well above the 2005 rate of 0.8%.

  2. Lisa Bouchard
    Lisa Bouchard says:

    This is so true! We’re in super-frugal mode until my husband finds a job but I think we’ll have to stay frugal for quite a long time afterwards to rebuild our savings.

    • FruGal
      FruGal says:

      Yay full-time lovers of frugality! You will find yourself way ahead if you continue down your frugal path. Thanks for sharing!

  3. browndude
    browndude says:

    Wonderful reminder! During good times the illusion of continued success is very high and it is easy to forget the frugal habits. Thank you for the great article.

  4. Cashville Skyline
    Cashville Skyline says:

    I can totally relate to these extremes. There’s always a reason to celebrate and stray from your savings goals. Maybe the secret is treating yourself to small indulgences so it doesn’t feel like such a sacrifice all the time.

  5. Pyper B.
    Pyper B. says:

    I agree, small treats might make it easier. I sometimes feel a slave to my finances when we try to pull the strings a little too tight.

Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. […] to up the amount of time your emergency fund should cover your expenses from 6 months to 8 months {as if most people even had 6 months’ worth of expenses set aside to begin with}. This is very sound advice…but perhaps it’s not reachable for you. After all, if it was easy […]

  2. […] If you use frugality in both the good times and the bad times, then you will eventually stockpile some money. This is a great thing! Once you have stockpiled enough to feed a healthy emergency fund—an amount of money that will pay between 6 and 8 months of bills—then it may be time to invest. There are two places to invest your money: a retirement account, and outside of a retirement account. I am going to assume that you are already saving money towards your retirement. So instead of discussing that, this article will focus on online share trading. […]

Comments are closed.