Did you ever think to lower your hernia operation cost ($3,900 – $8,900) by shopping around? Let me show you why you want to shop around for your next surgery, and how to estimate your costs.

Amanda’s Note: Do not shop around if you have an emergency. Shopping around is a luxury for procedures where you have a few days to a week at least to do some investigative work. Your health is your number one asset in life, so please be responsible with it.

laptop on a medical desk with stethoscope with text overlay "how to shop around for your next surgery"Have you ever thought about not getting surgery because of the prohibitive costs? Hernia operation costs and other operation costs can be really expensive, even with insurance, and so it might be tempting to do.

But it's definitely not always a good idea.

Take my sister, for example. In the beginning of August my sister went into the hospital for severe pain. She thought she had gallstones — my mother is a nurse and the two of them settled on this diagnosis from the symptoms — and tests at the hospital confirmed this. Her gall bladder needed to be removed through surgery.

The only problem is that she didn’t have health insurance, and she hadn’t had it for over two years. The tragic side to this is that she just recently had enough hours at work to be able to sign up for her employer’s health plan, and her benefits and coverage period were set to begin…on September 1, 2010.

Her initial reaction was to live through the pain and hold off on the surgery until her coverage was set to kick-in — just 26 precious days away — but a few days after the initial hospital trip her skin turned jaundice and she began to have more complications.

She ended up back in the hospital, and thank goodness she had enough sense to do so: a rather large gallstone was blocking her bile duct to her liver, causing her liver to stop functioning. The first surgery was to remove the large gallstone, and the second surgery was to remove her gall bladder. She is now healed and waiting on the arrival of her medical bill.

It Turns Out, You Can Shop Around for a Surgery

We’ve all seen those news stories in the last year or so when the newscasters compare pricing at hospitals for various surgeries. I watched these stories and was shocked to learn that rates for things like surgeries and giving birth vary from doctor to doctor and hospital to hospital; I thought that the going rate for a broken leg was set by some random standard, regulation, or hospital agreement.

I was also initially horrified at the idea of shopping around for a surgery like price shopping for salami.

And then something happened to me.

I went to a new dentist here in Texas and since I have never been to a dentist in Texas, by state law I had to have two consultations before they were able to do a cleaning. The first came with a $35 copay, and I assumed the second would be the same. During the second visit, the woman behind the glass said “$75”, and I winced in pain. I asked why she had not informed me that my second consultation’s copay would be so much more. And then something shocking happened — she said

“I can take the price down to $50, but that’s as low as I can go”. I thanked her, closed my mouth, and got out my check book.

I was initially horrified at the idea of shopping around for a surgery like I was price shopping for salami. Click To Tweet

In light of my sister’s plight and my recent experience of being offered a lower price at a doctor’s office, I decided to try shopping around for surgeries for myself and see if it is worth it. And I can tell you, it is. Hernia operation costs and other operation costs actually vary greatly!

I do not have a Inguinal hernia (nor can I pronounce it), but I wanted to choose a symptom that was benign enough to not excite people on the other end of the phone (I had visions of nurses screaming into the phone to get into an ambulance and get to the hospital right now while I was trying to price out a ruptured spleen or a burst appendix), and that was common enough that I could do the research.

How Much does Laparoscopic Hernia Surgery Cost?

According to Amino.com, the average hernia surgery cost is $7,743. This is both what you + your insurance will pay together (so long as you have health insurance, and your plan covers some of the cost).

I've based all of the prices on the same type of surgery: laparoscopic inguinal hernia repair.

But as you will quickly see, the prices vary greatly.

In fact, here in Houston, the prices vary between

So, what can YOU expect to pay (estimated, at least) for a hernia surgery? Amino has an awesome hernia calculator that can estimate your cost, based on your own health insurance plan. You'll definitely want to check that out.

For example, when I input my own information, and my location, then chose a doctor from the 104 matches they gave me, I clicked on “cost”, then saw that a hernia surgery would be $7,236.

That's some golden information!

But that's not all — because that's the total cost, not what I would pay out of pocket.

Based on my insurance provider, I clicked on “Calculate what I'll pay”, and it came back as $4,411 out of pocket cost to me.

Note: You'll always want to verify any estimate you receive, specifically with the doctor/facility where you choose to have your surgery. Verify beforehand!

Does Insurance Cover Hernia Surgery?

Your insurance company will likely cover your hernia surgery. It must be a health concern for them to do so, and there will be lots of other costs involved besides the surgery itself — so, you'll want to do the following:

  • Read up on the basics with what surgeries insurance will cover.
  • Call your own insurance company and find out what they will and will not cover.
  • Call the office/medical center where you want to have the surgery, and see if they'll give you an estimate of what you'll need to cover after your insurance pays their amount (this will help you verify that your insurance company will, in fact, pay some towards the hernia operation costs).

So, what exactly can you expect to pay for a hernia operation, and why should you shop around for this + other surgeries you might have?

Let's look at the comparison prices I found to answer these questions.

Hernia Surgery Cost Without Insurance

How much is hernia surgery without insurance? If you don't have insurance, and you need surgery for a hernia repair, then you're looking at spending thousands of dollars out of pocket.

In order to get an estimate, you'll need to call the facility where you'll get the surgery. Let them know you do not have insurance.

But before you do this, I highly recommend you do the following:

Hernia Surgery Cost with Insurance – Comparison Prices in Houston (including Houston Hernia Center)

How much does hernia surgery cost? I called around to various places within Houston to shop around for the hernia operation costs, and was surprised with what I found.

Note: Obviously, you might not be in the Houston area; but I'm showing you this as an example of what cost estimates will be + why you should shop around in your own area for hernia operation costs.

The Houston Hernia Center offers a low cost hernia surgery option for people without health insurance on the following hernia operations: Inguinal, Umbilical, Epigastric or Incisional Hernias. The cost is $3,900-4,900 per hernia with no complications. This price covers the surgeon’s fee, anesthesiologist fee, a State Certified Ambulatory Surgical center, mesh materials and the outpatient fee. At Riverside General Hospital, the same surgery (groin or abdominal) comes in at $16,100, and at the Kelsey-seybold ASC, the same surgical procedure is just $5,400. At Park Plaza Hospital the procedure will cost you $8,500. (Prices above are estimates provided by New Choice Health and/or phone conversations).

The most interesting conversation I had was with a financial counselor at Memorial Hermann Hospital, who said that the contracted rate for this surgery with my health insurance company, Blue Cross Blue Shield, was $1,991.

If I were paying for the surgery on my own and paid in full the day of, the cost would be $3,800. If I did not pay in full, the cost would be $8,900.

I was shocked!

I asked this woman why on earth they would charge so much more to an individual with no health insurance than to a health insurance company, and basically she said it’s because that is what the health insurance company was willing to pay. And can you imagine the law that allows a hospital to tack on $5100 if you choose to finance?

Most furniture stores that I’ve seen commercials for offer 0% financing for the first year on the agreed upon price that you leave the store with…could you imagine coming home with new leather sofas and finding out right after you child dropped juice on them that now they will cost you an extra $3,000?

Low Cost Hernia Surgery – Medical Tourism

If you don't have thousands of dollars to pay out of pocket costs for a hernia operation…would you consider having an operation done in Poland?

What about Belgium?

Medical Tourism is when someone travels to a different country in order to get some sort of medical care (dental, vision, medical surgeries, operations, etc.). They do this because they'll either be receiving better care, or be receiving good care at a better price.

According to healism.com, a hernia repair in Belgium within the next 1-3 months would cost me between $410-$500. The same surgery in Mexico goes for about $340-$410. For a top-notch Bumrungrad hospital in Thailand, the cost is between $3,616 and $5,397. You will also have to add in the cost of travel, food, and hotel rooms for this option.

Hernia Surgery Cost Blue Cross Blue Shield – Insurance Considerations

I happened to have Blue Cross Blue Shield health insurance when I shopped around for this hernia surgery. So, I went ahead and called my personal insurance company to get the lowdown on pricing and my part of the bill.

My copayment would be $150 per day (if the surgery is inpatient), as well as 20% of the bill.

You can quickly see why it would be in the favor of someone with insurance to shop around as well; 20% of $16,100 ($3,220) is a lot more than 20% of $5,400 ($1080).

Note: you'll want to call your own insurance company and find out what portion of the bill you'll be liable to pay, and what part they will cover. Is it a 20% or 40%? What is the copayment for inpatient surgery, versus copayment for an outpatient surgery?

In Conclusion: You Need to Shop Around

From what I gathered while doing the research for this article, it is not common for patients to ask pricing in advance.

Yet it is in your favor to do so as the price differentials can be startling.

If you have an upcoming surgery — inpatient or outpatient — that you would like to price, start by visiting New Choice Health to get some estimates, such as finding out umbilical hernia surgery cost vs. cost of private umbilical hernia repair.

Call around to several hospitals, clinics, or centers and ask to speak with the billing department or a financial counselor to get some cold, hard dollar amounts. If you have health insurance, you will then want to speak with a rep from your health insurance company to find out what your copay and coinsurance rates will be.

For those without health insurance, you can work with hospital financial counselors and bill payment centers to set up a payment schedule, and/or apply for Care Credit. In fact, it may be in your favor to have a loan through Care Credit (0% financing) before having the surgery so that you can pay in full the day of and substantially reduce your bill. Emergency insurance applications are available as well — talk with the hospital that you are having the emergency surgery at.

A final thought: my health insurance rep informed me that health care surgeries and procedures are cheaper outside of city limits, which is something you may wish to keep in mind when trying to save money.

The following two tabs change content below.
Amanda L. Grossman is a Certified Financial Education Instructor, Plutus Foundation Grant Recipient, and founder of Frugal Confessions. Over the last 10 years, her money work helping people with how to save money and how to manage money has been featured in Kiplinger, Washington Post, U.S. News & World Report, Business Insider, LifeHacker, Woman's World, Woman's Day, ABC 13 Houston, Keybank, and more. Read more here.
15 replies
  1. Thomas Adams says:

    I am looking for the best price on a laparoscopic Hernia operation in the Dallas area

  2. Susan Porkovich says:

    As an American who has lived in the South of France for 15 years, I would have to agree that there are plenty of high quality options outside of the USA. Private hospitals here (Tzanck Clinic) charge $600 for the surgery and $300 for the Doctors. A home nurse to come and change your bandages and check on infection costs $200 per week! The care is at a much higher level than I experienced through Kaiser in California. You can fly in, recuperate on the beach, and have a nurse check on you in your hotel for less than half the cost in the USA.

  3. Joe P says:

    Hi Amanda-

    I will have inguinal surgery too. I have been looking around and will probably have my surgery in Mexico.

    Where in Mexico did you look? I would love to find that kind of price, and I know that the doctors in Mexico are well trained…at least most of them are.

    I did see a place in Maryland which has a good idea. Flat fee of $1900. It would be great if there was a similar place here- is tempting to fly there, but I doubt I will.

    Thanks for the post.

  4. Russell says:

    Admiring the commitment you put into your website and in depth
    information you present. It’s nice to come across a blog every once in a while that isn’t the same out of date rehashed material.
    Wonderful read! I’ve saved your site and I’m adding your RSS feeds to my Google account.

  5. Bradford Van Dam says:

    If you have an income level below the poverty level you can get hernia surgery for free….yes free. I have noticed that if you go to type in free hernia surgery there a a couple of web sites that will give you some ideas on how to get free surgery.

    In addition there are many hospitals that offer either assistance for those with no insurance or no cost at all. There are many free health care organizations everywhere and the best way to look is through the internet. It may take some time making phone calls and surfing the web but free is good.

    You don’t have to go to The North Pole to get surgery cheap either but once again you do need to surf the web. Try typing cheap surgery for what ever the condition and you might be surprised.

    In addition there is a web site called http://www.clinicaltrials.gov/ and there are many hospitals doing research. Not for a hernia at this time that I could find but other medical conditions and other surgeries. They will actually PAY YOU TO HAVE SURGERY OR HEALTH CARE. People imagine that these research hospitals are using doctors with no experience or doing harmful experiments. Most of these doctors have over ten-twenty years of experience. In addition if you read the details of the study it will let you know if they are testing for any safety issues or not.

    Here is my favorite hernia web site for FREE SURGERY.


  6. Archer says:

    I like this web site and have absolutely saved it. I’m going to expect to go through in particulars on my trip

  7. thai medical vacation says:

    I like what you guys are up too. This kind of clever work and reporting! Keep up the very good works guys I’ve you guys to my blogroll.

  8. Laurence Kinabrew says:

    Hi there, just became aware of your blog through Google, and found that it’s truly informative. I am going to watch out for brussels. I’ll be grateful if you continue this in future. A lot of people will be benefited from your writing. Cheers!

  9. Dr Dean says:

    Amanda, just to clarify for your readers:
    If they have private insurance, their co-pay and deductible for surgery is not based on the Docs quoted fee for the surgery.

    It is based on the Insurance Companies contractual agreement with that Docs office.

    In other words, if my fee for a hysterectomy is 5 grand, but the insurance only approves $2500. Then the 20% copay is based on the $2500, not the 5,000.

    If you are paying cash, most docs will discount significantly-at least down to their insurance reimbursement level. But you have to ask, and usually pay cash up front.

    It is always in your best interest to get all the facts upfront.

    And if you think things are crazy now, wait till Obama-care really gets going. It’s like so-called tax simplification-it never happens-just get more regulations/more paper work…
    Good post!

    • FruGal says:

      Thank you for the clarification and information! I appreciate your comments.

  10. Car Negotiation Coach says:

    Amanda, I’m not sure everyone else likes reading about hernias, but shockingly I do!

    I’ve got a mild type(hiatal), but bad enough that I have crappy heartburn all the time. I just went through a similar expensive pain in the butt just to get the endoscopy diagnosing what I had. Now I don’t know if I have the stomach (insert joke here) to go through the whole shopping around thing myself for an actual procedure.

    Love to hear if you end up going to Poland 🙂

    • Amanda L. Grossman says:

      Hello Car Negotiation Coach!

      Thank you for sharing (and the pun:)). I definitely won’t be going to Poland…good luck in your shopping around!

  11. Brian says:

    Good recommendations to help patients save money. We focus alot on helping patients negotiate lower medical bills. By agreeing to pay bills promptly, you can save alot of money by asking for a discount. We’ve seen providers willing to offer up to 50% or more at PaymentClinic.com to help patients save money in return for faster bill payment.


Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *